
Washington Irving Authorial Presentation Copy
Dark-puce publisher-issued front board
5 curated visualsA visual, copy-by-copy record of the surviving first-edition books: where they are, how they are bound, what inscriptions and ownership marks they preserve, and how each copy moved through private hands and institutional collections.
Images are included only when they illuminate the physical book, an inscription, a binding, a bookplate, a provenance mark, or an associated document. Representative photographs explicitly identified as belonging to another copy were omitted, as were unrelated screenshots and uncertain images.
37 of 42 records now contain at least one curated copy-specific image or associated evidence item. Records without a reliable photograph are left blank rather than filled with a substitute.
Private Collection
Texas
Original dark-puce publisher-issued boards with silver-gray decoration.
Verified
Authorial presentation by Charles R. Hale, Christmas 1858.
Charles R. Hale → Washington Irving → unresolved gap → Owen Family Medical Archive → Private Collection
The inscription identifies Hale as one of the authors. The ownership chain between Irving and the Owen family archive remains unresolved and is deliberately shown as a gap.





Private Collection
Texas
Original cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration; preserved in a modern protective box.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
Jeremy Norman → Private Collection
This copy provides a direct physical comparison for the cream binding family and for the edition’s chromolithographed interior.



Harvard University, Houghton Library
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Original dark-puce publisher-issued boards with silver-gray decoration.
Verified
Gift of Mrs. Henry D. Gilpin to William Everett, January 1, 1859.
Mrs. Henry D. Gilpin → William Everett → Harvard University
The copy preserves the presentation inscription, Everett bookplate, Harvard acquisition evidence, and the distinctive dark-puce binding.






Arizona State University, Hayden Library
Tempe, Arizona
Original cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No authorial presentation inscription documented.
Effingham B. Morris → Arizona State University
The surviving photographs document the original cream binding, its decorated edge, and the lithographed committee and dedication leaves.



Philomathean Society, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
Gift of Reuben C. Hale to Edward C. Herrick, January 21, 1859.
Reuben C. Hale → Edward C. Herrick → Philomathean Society
Herrick was Yale College’s librarian and treasurer and a pioneering American observer of meteor showers. Reuben C. Hale was the father of report author Charles R. Hale. Dashboard correction: the binding is cream, not red.

Philomathean Society, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Red publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
Gift of Henry D. Gilpin to J. Francis Fisher, January 1859.
Henry D. Gilpin → J. Francis Fisher → Philomathean Society
The inscription has been re-read as a gift from Gilpin to Fisher. The recipient is identified in the project as Joshua Francis Fisher; the identification remains appropriately qualified in the underlying research.

Philomathean Society, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Red publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No ownership provenance or inscription identified.
One of two red-binding copies held by the Society. The only image supplied for the two red copies is representative rather than a separately identified photograph of C007.

Philomathean Society, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Brown publisher-issued rear board with gold decoration; original front board missing.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No ownership provenance or inscription identified.
The surviving rear board is the only binding image presently available for this copy.

Kislak Center, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No early presentation inscription identified.
Mrs. Horace Binney → Kislak Center
A newer University of Pennsylvania bookplate is present. The path to Penn before the documented institutional association remains unknown.

Kislak Center, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
Twentieth-century institutional gift, not an 1858–59 presentation.
Harriet Cutler Cunningham Binney → Kislak Center
The donor has been identified as Harriet Cutler Cunningham Binney (1885–1981), widow of Dr. Horace Binney. The copy’s earlier ownership remains undocumented.



Kislak Center, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Fine late-nineteenth-century rebinding; not the publisher’s original boards; earlier Dewey markings retained.
Verified
No early presentation inscription identified.
Julia Biddle bequest → University of Pennsylvania → Kislak Center
The bequest bookplate is documented. Identification with Julia Cox Biddle is strong; the proposal that the volume had belonged to her husband, Thomas Alexander Biddle, remains a working inference rather than a confirmed fact.


Kislak Center, University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Later institutional binding with Dewey markings and an earlier “Special” designation.
Verified
No early presentation inscription identified.
Gift of E. F. Smith → University of Pennsylvania → Kislak Center
The bookplate names Edgar Fahs Smith. Project research concludes it was probably an institutional gift or purchase supported by Smith rather than part of his chemistry-focused personal collection; that distinction remains an evidence-based inference.



Library Company of Philadelphia
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Original cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No presentation inscription recorded.
John Lambert → Abington Library Society → Library Company of Philadelphia (on deposit)
Ex-libris evidence identifies John Lambert. The copy has been on deposit from the Abington Library Society since December 9, 1959. Dashboard correction: this is the cream Lambert copy, not C014.



Library Company of Philadelphia
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Half-leather and marbled-paper rebinding.
Verified / Attribution Under Review
Handwritten “Gift of the Authors” inscription; precise authorship classification remains under review.
Library Company accession 2774.Q; earlier chain unresolved
The inscription is handwritten, not the standard printed committee leaf. A possible Charles R. Hale handwriting attribution is a working hypothesis awaiting independent paleographic review and is not presented here as confirmed.



Haverford College, Quaker & Special Collections
Haverford, Pennsylvania
Red publisher-issued boards with dark-red endpapers.
Verified
Birthday gift from Ellen Maria Camac to her uncle James Albert Bancker, February 4, 1859.
Ellen Maria Camac → James Albert Bancker → Richard Jenney → Haverford College
The flyleaf inscription and embossed J.A.B. ownership stamp establish the early association. The copy later entered the library of Richard Jenney before reaching Haverford.




The Huntington Library
San Marino, California
Later leather-type binding with the original wrappers retained inside.
Verified
Authorial presentation by Charles R. Hale to his aunt Mary J. Welles, Christmas 1858.
Charles R. Hale → Mary J. Welles → Alma Freeman Welles → Huntington Library
Mary Jane Hale Welles was Charles R. Hale’s paternal aunt and the wife of Gideon Welles. The volume also bears Alma Freeman Welles’s later ownership signature and a bookseller’s corroborating note.




The Huntington Library
San Marino, California
Brown publisher-issued boards with dull copper/gold stamping.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No presentation inscription or earlier ownership provenance documented.
Huntington staff compared the binding with the Philomathean Society brown/gold copy and confirmed the binding-family match. Representative interior photographs in Appendix A were intentionally omitted here because they are not photographs of C017.

The Huntington Library
San Marino, California
Orange publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
Jay T. Last → Huntington Library, 2005
The copy forms part of the Jay T. Last Collection of Graphic Arts and Social History. Representative interior photographs in Appendix A were omitted because they are not photographs of this copy.

Duke University, Rubenstein Library
Durham, North Carolina
Later plain institutional binding with library titling on the spine.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No earlier ownership provenance documented.
The surviving photographs document the later binding rather than the original publisher-issued boards.


University of Wisconsin–Madison, Special Collections
Madison, Wisconsin
Cream publisher-issued boards.
Verified
Presentation inscription dated Baltimore, March 5, 1859, “ex dono amicitiae”; presenter unidentified.
Joshua I. Cohen → George S. MacManus Co. → Michael Zinman → Michael Laird → University of Wisconsin–Madison
The copy’s modern bookselling chain is unusually well documented. The surviving inscription photograph is the most important visual evidence presently available in the project folder.

Case Western Reserve University, Kelvin Smith Library
Cleveland, Ohio
Red publisher-issued boards; spine rebacked in black cloth; hinge and repair reinforcements.
Verified
Gift from George D. Morgan to his brother Rev. W. F. Morgan, New Year’s 1859.
George D. Morgan → Rev. W. F. Morgan → Willis Thornton → Western Reserve University
George D. Morgan was married to Caroline Amelia Hale, aunt of Charles R. Hale. A direct Hale-to-Morgan transfer remains a working hypothesis, not a documented fact. The Thornton estate bookplate and later circulation evidence survive.




New York Public Library, Stephen A. Schwarzman Building
New York, New York
Original brown publisher-issued boards with slightly metallic gold stamping; housed in a later library box.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
Estate of Marion Olmstead Mahan → New York Public Library
The estate bookplate records the institutional gift. No earlier ownership history has yet been identified.



Lambeth Palace Library
London, United Kingdom
Brown publisher-issued boards.
Verified
Authorial presentation by Charles R. Hale.
Charles R. Hale → Archibald Campbell Tait → unresolved gap → Lambeth Palace Library
The project preserves Hale’s accompanying presentation letter to Tait. The letter is associated evidence and is displayed as such; it is not a photograph of the binding.


Private Collection
New York
Cream publisher-issued boards.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No ownership provenance or presentation inscription documented.
No copy-specific photograph has yet been curated into this board. Images are not substituted from another copy.
State Library of Pennsylvania, Rare Collections Library
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No earlier ownership provenance documented.
The project photographs document the front board, spine, and sphinx-decorated rear board.



State Library of Pennsylvania, Rare Collections Library
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Later binding; original binding not retained.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No earlier ownership provenance documented.
No copy-specific image is presently filed in the copy’s Images folder. No substitute image has been used.
State Library of Pennsylvania, Rare Collections Library
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Later binding; original binding not retained.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No earlier ownership provenance documented.
No copy-specific image is presently filed in the copy’s Images folder. No substitute image has been used.
Dartmouth College, Rauner Special Collections Library
Hanover, New Hampshire
Brown publisher-issued boards with gold decoration.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No presentation inscription or earlier ownership provenance documented.
Front and rear board photographs document the original binding and its wear.


University of Oxford, Bodleian Library
Oxford, United Kingdom
Red publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No authorial presentation inscription documented.
Francis Llewellyn Griffith and Nora Griffith → Ashmolean Museum Library → Bodleian Libraries
The photographs document the binding, spine, annotations, Griffith ex-libris stamp, and Ashmolean institutional stamp, making the repository chain visible on the object itself.






Brown University, John Hay Library
Providence, Rhode Island
Brown publisher-issued boards; later spine reinforcement is visible.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No presentation inscription or earlier ownership provenance documented.
Front and rear photographs document the original decorated boards and their condition.


Brown University, John Hay Library
Providence, Rhode Island
Red publisher-issued boards with black decoration and later spine reinforcement.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No presentation inscription or earlier ownership provenance documented.
The copy-specific front-board photograph confirms the red binding family.

Boston Public Library, McKim Building
Boston, Massachusetts
Rebound in green buckram in 1960; title page missing.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
Accessioned by Boston Public Library in 1939; earlier ownership not documented.
The visual record documents the institutional rebinding rather than an original publisher-issued board.

Getty Research Institute, Research Library
Los Angeles, California
Cream publisher-issued boards.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No presentation inscription or earlier ownership provenance documented.
No copy-specific image is presently filed in the copy’s Images folder. No substitute image has been used.
Carnegie Mellon University, Special Collections
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Later plain binding; original publisher-issued boards not retained.
Verified
No early authorial presentation inscription documented.
Charles C. Mellor → Carnegie Mellon University
The photographs document the later spine and back cover, title page, and a Charles C. Mellor ownership/donation note.




University of Georgia, Hargrett Rare Book and Manuscript Library
Athens, Georgia
Cream publisher-issued boards retained within later corner and spine reinforcement.
Verified
Later association gift from Ann Pamela Cunningham to Charles C. Jones, Mount Vernon, July 19, 1872.
Ann Pamela Cunningham → Col. Charles C. Jones → University of Georgia
This is a later association copy, not an authorial presentation. The inscription directly links the founder of the Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association with Georgia historian Charles C. Jones.


American Antiquarian Society, Research Library
Worcester, Massachusetts
Cream publisher-issued boards.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
Bookseller transaction documented; earlier chain not fully established.
The currently curated image is documentary evidence: a bookseller invoice and detailed bibliographical description. A clean copy-specific binding photograph has not yet been selected, so none is substituted.

American Antiquarian Society, Research Library
Worcester, Massachusetts
Brown publisher-issued boards.
Verified
Authorial presentation by Samuel Huntington Jones, one of the three report authors, January 10, 1859.
Samuel Huntington Jones → George William Childs → American Antiquarian Society
The accompanying letter asks Childs to accept the report and is signed by S. Huntington Jones. This is an authorial presentation copy, not merely a later association.


Princeton University, Rare Books and Special Collections
Princeton, New Jersey
Cream publisher-issued boards with black decoration.
Verified
No authorial presentation inscription documented.
Nethercliffe, Ochre Point, Newport, Rhode Island → Princeton Graphic Arts Collection → Princeton Rare Books and Special Collections
The image set documents the boards, spine, Nethercliffe/Ochre Point labels, Princeton collection labels, title page, and interior lithographed leaves.






Princeton University, Rare Books and Special Collections
Princeton, New Jersey
Brown publisher-issued boards with gold/copper decoration.
Verified
Later ownership inscription; no authorial presentation documented.
Emma Stevenson → Mrs. Tappan → unresolved gap → Princeton University Library
The photographs document the complete binding, ownership inscription, library label, title page, committee and dedication leaves, and a richly chromolithographed interior page.








Villanova University, Falvey Library, Special Collections
Radnor Township, Pennsylvania
Later plain brown cloth binding.
Verified
No presentation inscription identified.
No earlier ownership provenance documented.
Two copy-specific photographs document the unlettered later binding. No original board is claimed or shown.


University of Cambridge, Waddleton Collection
Cambridge, United Kingdom
Dark-puce publisher-issued boards.
Verified
Presented by Rev. Thomas K. Conrad to Mrs. B. G. Godfrey, his friend and parishioner/pastoral acquaintance.
Rev. Thomas K. Conrad → Mrs. B. G. Godfrey → Cambridge University Library
Conrad was the Philomathean member who presented the Society with a plaster cast of the Rosetta Stone near the close of the 1855–56 college year. The current C041 Images folder contains material that could not be confidently separated from Princeton photographs, so no questionable image is displayed.
New York Public Library, Stephen A. Schwarzman Building
New York, New York
Later binding; original publisher-issued boards not retained.
Verified
Ownership/association inscription, not an authorial presentation.
C. V. S. Roosevelt — strongly identified as Cornelius Van Schaack Roosevelt → Robert Leighton Stuart → R. L. Stuart Collection → Lenox Library, 1892 → New York Public Library, 1895
The surviving inscription records C. V. S. Roosevelt’s gift to Robert Leighton Stuart. The Roosevelt identification is strong but remains explicitly qualified.

A quick visual survey of copies for which reliable photographs or documentary evidence are presently available. The complete image sets and captions remain inside each expanded Census record.

Dark-puce publisher-issued front board
5 curated visuals
Cream publisher-issued front board
3 curated visuals
Dark-puce publisher-issued front board
6 curated visuals
Cream publisher-issued front board
3 curated visuals
Cream publisher-issued front board
1 curated visual
Red publisher-issued front board
1 curated visual
Representative red front board supplied for the Society’s two red copies
1 curated visual
Surviving brown rear board; original front board missing
1 curated visual
Kislak Center first-edition holdings photograph
1 curated visual
Cream publisher-issued front board
3 curated visuals
Julia Biddle bequest bookplate
2 curated visuals
The two rebound Kislak copies
3 curated visuals
Original board and pastedown
3 curated visuals
Half-leather marbled front board
3 curated visuals
Red publisher-issued front board
4 curated visuals
Rebound front board
4 curated visuals
Brown publisher-issued front board
1 curated visual
Orange publisher-issued front board
1 curated visual
Later rebound front board
2 curated visuals
Joshua I. Cohen presentation inscription, Baltimore, March 5, 1859
1 curated visual
Red front board and black-cloth rebacking
4 curated visuals
Brown publisher-issued front board
3 curated visuals
Charles R. Hale presentation letter to Archibald Campbell Tait — first page
2 curated visuals
Cream publisher-issued front board
3 curated visuals
Brown publisher-issued front board
2 curated visuals
Red publisher-issued front board
6 curated visuals
Brown publisher-issued front board
2 curated visuals
Red publisher-issued front board
1 curated visual
Boston Public Library institutional rebound
1 curated visual
Spine
4 curated visuals
Cream publisher board retained within later reinforcement
2 curated visuals
Bookseller invoice and detailed bibliographical description — documentary evidence
1 curated visual
Brown publisher-issued front board
2 curated visuals
Cream publisher-issued front board
6 curated visuals
Brown publisher-issued front board
8 curated visuals
Later plain-cloth front board
2 curated visuals
C. V. S. Roosevelt inscription to Robert Leighton Stuart
1 curated visualAuthorial presentation by Charles R. Hale, Christmas 1858.
Charles R. Hale → Washington Irving → unresolved gap → Owen Family Medical Archive → Private CollectionGift of Mrs. Henry D. Gilpin to William Everett, January 1, 1859.
Mrs. Henry D. Gilpin → William Everett → Harvard UniversityGift of Reuben C. Hale to Edward C. Herrick, January 21, 1859.
Reuben C. Hale → Edward C. Herrick → Philomathean SocietyGift of Henry D. Gilpin to J. Francis Fisher, January 1859.
Henry D. Gilpin → J. Francis Fisher → Philomathean SocietyBirthday gift from Ellen Maria Camac to her uncle James Albert Bancker, February 4, 1859.
Ellen Maria Camac → James Albert Bancker → Richard Jenney → Haverford CollegeAuthorial presentation by Charles R. Hale to his aunt Mary J. Welles, Christmas 1858.
Charles R. Hale → Mary J. Welles → Alma Freeman Welles → Huntington LibraryPresentation inscription dated Baltimore, March 5, 1859, “ex dono amicitiae”; presenter unidentified.
Joshua I. Cohen → George S. MacManus Co. → Michael Zinman → Michael Laird → University of Wisconsin–MadisonGift from George D. Morgan to his brother Rev. W. F. Morgan, New Year’s 1859.
George D. Morgan → Rev. W. F. Morgan → Willis Thornton → Western Reserve UniversityAuthorial presentation by Charles R. Hale.
Charles R. Hale → Archibald Campbell Tait → unresolved gap → Lambeth Palace LibraryLater association gift from Ann Pamela Cunningham to Charles C. Jones, Mount Vernon, July 19, 1872.
Ann Pamela Cunningham → Col. Charles C. Jones → University of GeorgiaAuthorial presentation by Samuel Huntington Jones, one of the three report authors, January 10, 1859.
Samuel Huntington Jones → George William Childs → American Antiquarian SocietyPresented by Rev. Thomas K. Conrad to Mrs. B. G. Godfrey, his friend and parishioner/pastoral acquaintance.
Rev. Thomas K. Conrad → Mrs. B. G. Godfrey → Cambridge University Library